Robots in Harm’s Way — Bryan Clark

America at Sea: Bryan Clark

America at Sea: Voices That Matter is a 45-day maritime conversation hosted by Americans for a Stronger Navy with U.S. Maritime Action and moderated by Capt. Brent Sadler, USN (Ret.). Each voice answers the same three questions: What’s working? What’s the biggest barrier? What would you fix first?

Bryan Clark is a senior fellow at the Hudson Institute in Washington, D.C., and director of its Center for Defense Concepts and Technology. A retired Navy submariner, he served as director of the Commander’s Action Group for Chief of Naval Operations Adm. Jonathan Greenert and spent three years in the Navy’s assessment division before joining the think tank world [1].

His answers are the kind that start arguments, and that is the point. He is willing to say what many in the naval community would rather not.

https://twitter.com/StrongerNavy/status/XXXXXXXXXX

What’s Working: Sailors Under Fire

Clark starts with the people. Against the Houthis and now Iran, the Navy’s air and missile defenses have worked, and its ships have sustained high readiness through months of real combat. It is the first time in generations that American sailors have operated under sustained fire.

“You train and you train and you test these systems out and you’re not totally sure if they’re going to work when the time comes to use them against a real threat. And we’ve seen that across the board. Those have been effective in this fight.”

He sees that experience as preparation. The Houthis and Iran have given sailors confidence they can do the job they would face against China.

The Biggest Barrier: Buying Differently, and Fielding Robots

Clark names two barriers.

The first is munitions. The weapons the Navy built to counter the Soviets and the Chinese are overkill against cheaper Iranian threats, and the stockpile has paid the price. The acquisition system makes it hard to buy something deliberately less capable but far more affordable.

“The normal acquisition process doesn’t give you that flexibility to say, I want to buy something that’s not as good as the best thing I can buy.”

The second is unmanned systems. Iran, the Houthis, Russia, and Ukraine have all shifted to drones. The U.S. Navy has struggled to make that transition, partly because it lacks the process to deploy robots into a theater the way it deploys ships and aircraft.

“I would rather put those robots in harm’s way rather than a bunch of people, and I’d rather use the robots’ service life up instead of burning through the service life of my ships.”

He adds that large, highly integrated warships cannot change quickly, while Ukraine updates its drones in days or weeks. His answer is to keep a core traditional fleet while buying more of the new technology now, rather than treating it as an add-on.

Fix One Thing: Readiness Before New Hulls

This is where Clark gets controversial, and he says so. His first fix would be the Navy’s readiness accounts, even at the expense of some new construction.

His reasoning is about the bills that come after the ribbon-cutting. By his estimate, every dollar spent buying a ship brings about five dollars in operating, maintenance, and personnel costs over its life, and those future bills are not funded in advance.

“We’re signing up future administrations, future Congresses to pay those bills. And our experience is they don’t do it.”

He notes that the Navy has retired more ships than it has built over the last decade, and that today’s fleet, about half the size it was 40 years ago, costs roughly the same to operate, crew, and maintain.

“We have a readiness crisis in the Navy today that doesn’t get solved by just buying a couple more ships. It gets solved by putting the money into readiness and managing the fleet at a size where it’s sustainable, rather than signing up a future administration to have a hollow force that is big on paper but not so big out in the water.”

The Takeaway

Clark’s answers challenge a comfortable assumption, including one this organization holds: that more ships is always the answer. His warning is that a fleet the nation will not pay to sustain becomes a hollow force. That is the same lesson behind our own motto, you can’t surge what you didn’t sustain.

Not everyone will agree with his prescription. Many will argue the answer is a bigger budget, not a trade between ships and readiness. But his question deserves an answer from anyone making the case for a larger fleet: who pays to keep it at sea?

—

About America at Sea

America at Sea: Voices That Matter is a 45-day maritime conversation launched October 18, 2026, by Americans for a Stronger Navy with U.S. Maritime Action. Moderated by Capt. Brent Sadler, USN (Ret.), the series asks shipbuilders, mariners, industry leaders, the Navy community, and policy experts the same three questions. A common-ground report will be delivered to policymakers, their staffs, and the public at the end of November.

Learn more: StrongerNavy.org

—

About the Guest

Bryan Clark is a senior fellow and director of the Center for Defense Concepts and Technology at the Hudson Institute. A retired Navy submariner, he previously served as special assistant to the Chief of Naval Operations and director of his Commander’s Action Group, and worked in the Navy’s assessment division. Before joining Hudson, he was a senior fellow at the Center for Strategic and Budgetary Assessments.

—

References

[1] Hudson Institute, Bryan Clark, Senior Fellow and Director, Center for Defense Concepts and Technology: https://www.hudson.org