Tactics Without Strategy — Craig Hooper

America at Sea: Craig Hooper

America at Sea: Voices That Matter is a maritime conversation hosted by Americans for a Stronger Navy with U.S. Maritime Action and moderated by Capt. Brent Sadler, USN (Ret.). Each voice answers the same three questions: What’s working? What’s the biggest barrier? What would you fix first?

Craig Hooper got hooked on the Navy as a ten-year-old, when his father took him to see the carriers at Norfolk and the submarines at Groton. He came to naval issues from public health and infectious disease, lectured at the Naval Postgraduate School, and served as vice president of sales, marketing and external affairs at Austal USA [1]. He co-authored the 2017 CSBA study Restoring American Seapower [2], writes about the Navy and the maritime industry for Forbes, and is the founder and CEO of the Themistocles Advisory Group [3]. He also helped shape the SHIPS for America Act [4].

He doesn’t pull punches, and he tells good stories.

What’s Working: Tactics

Hooper’s answer is one word: tactics. From the outside, he says, the Navy has been in nearly nonstop confrontation and has come through it without much loss. That shows the fleet can go into harm’s way, operate under very challenging conditions, and win.

But the strength carries a warning. Being second to none in tactics and technology isn’t enough if you don’t know how to apply it.

“If you don’t know how to apply that on a grander scale, on a strategic level, I think that leads you into peril. And I think that’s where we are today. We have focused on tactics so much, it’s distorted the way that we look at the maritime and the way that we use the Navy.”

The Biggest Barrier: Careerism, and No One in Charge

The first barrier, he says, is careerism. Focusing on tactics and warfighting is comforting because it gives you an answer: build the do-everything ship and shoot stuff. You don’t have to take risks. But you run the risk of optimizing for the wrong battle and the wrong campaign.

The harder path is for a naval leader with the guts to say where the Navy can make the biggest difference, such as the open global commons, the undersea, or the Antarctic, places where America may need to be present before somebody else gets there. Then that leader has to put a career on the line and debate all comers.

“I don’t see that type of leader in the Navy, right? I see a lot of sort of feigned helplessness and powerlessness where people could be stepping up and doing more.”

The second barrier is that maritime policy and Navy policy overlap, and no one owns the overlap.

“There’s nobody that’s empowered in Washington to sort of blend all those areas together into a cohesive use case.”

China, he notes, has a long-term strategy, and it lets Beijing do amazing things with assets that wouldn’t count for much in a war, like its militarized fishing fleets.

Then he goes after the revolving door. Too many senior leaders, he says, spend the last five or so years of their careers auditioning for a vice president job or a major contract.

“Quid pro quo is alive and well in Washington… It’s an unwise thing to be making decisions knowing full well that you’ll probably get a nice cushy job at the end of it from a grateful industrial partner. That’s not cool. It’s not cool in my book.”

Three Days of Yelling

Hooper knows the culture firsthand. Early on, as a lecturer at the Naval Postgraduate School, he wrote a tongue-in-cheek blog about the Navy. Eventually he got a call: an admiral was asking questions, and he had to go see the JAG.

His favorite experience in Washington was the opposite. A grab bag of people, ideologically different and from inside and outside government, were summoned to CNA for three days to talk about naval strategy.

“We spent three days just yelling at each other. I mean, it was vicious, man. And it was a great time. It was a great time because at the end of it, we had the foundations for the SHIPS Act.”

The only reason they got to do it, he says, is that the big wheels in Washington thought the group was insignificant. A lot of what they wrote got watered down, but more of it went through than didn’t.

He contrasts that fearless debate with what he sees today, and points to John Lehman’s account of how the Navy hashed out its 1980s Maritime Strategy, a long-term strategy that worked [5]. Today, he argues, leaders are so fearful they can brook no dissent.

“It takes some high-level leadership that’s tolerant to do that.”

Fix One Thing: A Maritime Coordinator, and a Look at Ungoverned Spaces

His first fix is leadership: install a maritime coordinator in the cabinet who pulls together all the scattered pieces of maritime policy and authority, including trade policy, environmental policy and the polar portfolio. He would go further, peeling the Coast Guard out of the Department of Homeland Security and combining it with NOAA and other agencies in one organization.

The SHIPS for America Act moves in a similar direction. It would create a presidentially appointed Maritime Security Advisor to coordinate maritime policy across the government [6].

His second fix is a team that studies ungoverned spaces, which he calls some of the most important and conflict-ridden areas, with the highest threat of conflict in the future. A little thought now goes a long way, he says, and he points to the South China Sea.

“It probably would have been a lot easier to deal with a few sailors standing on a sandy beach waving a flag than it is dealing with a whole integrated bastion.”

Answering the big maritime strategic questions first, he argues, will tell the Navy what force structure to build.

The Takeaway

Hooper’s three answers make one argument. The Navy is very good at fighting, but nobody is in charge of deciding what the fight is for. Fix that with leaders willing to argue, a single coordinator for maritime policy, and a hard look at the places nobody is watching yet, and the ships, training and force structure follow.

He also shows it can be done. Three days of yelling in a room produced the foundations of the most ambitious maritime bill in a generation.

About America at Sea

America at Sea: Voices That Matter is a 45-day maritime conversation launched October 18, 2026, by Americans for a Stronger Navy with U.S. Maritime Action. Moderated by Capt. Brent Sadler, USN (Ret.), the series asks shipbuilders, mariners, industry leaders, the Navy community, and policy experts the same three questions. A common-ground report will be delivered to policymakers, their staffs, and the public at the end of November. Views expressed are the speaker’s own, and featuring a view is not an endorsement.

Learn more: StrongerNavy.org

About the Guest

Craig Hooper is the founder and CEO of the Themistocles Advisory Group, a consulting firm specializing in maritime and national security strategy, and a longtime Forbes contributor on naval and maritime affairs. He has lectured at the Naval Postgraduate School, served as vice president of sales, marketing and external affairs at Austal USA, and co-authored the 2017 CSBA study Restoring American Seapower: A New Fleet Architecture for the United States Navy.

References

[1] MarineLink, “Hooper VP Sales, Marketing, Austal USA,” April 28, 2011; NextNavy.com, “About Craig Hooper” (Austal USA, 2011 to 2013).
[2] Center for Strategic and Budgetary Assessments, Restoring American Seapower: A New Fleet Architecture for the United States Navy, 2017.
[3] WorkBoat, contributor profile: Craig Hooper, founder and CEO of the Themistocles Advisory Group.
[4] The SHIPS for America Act was first introduced December 19, 2024, by Sens. Mark Kelly and Todd Young and Reps. John Garamendi and Trent Kelly, and reintroduced April 30, 2025.
[5] John F. Lehman, Oceans Ventured: Winning the Cold War at Sea (W.W. Norton, 2018).
[6] The reintroduced SHIPS for America Act would establish an Office of the Maritime Security Advisor, appointed by the president.